Monday, November 30, 2020
19.3 C
Home Human Rights The future for 19,000 released prisoners

The future for 19,000 released prisoners

On 8 May, Justice and Correctional Services Minister Ronald Lamola announced that 19 000 low-risk inmates will receive early parole in efforts to decongest prisons during the COVID-19 outbreak. Mike Batley welcomes the decision but warns that released prisoners will require close accompaniment from the public sector and civil society to reintegrate them into their communities, especially during the current economic slump.

Recently a number of organisations under the banner of The Detention Justice Forum sent an open letter to the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services regarding the decision to release 19000 inmates. The full text of the letter can be found here.

The response of the public to the Minister’s decision was well captured by Zapiro. In view of this understandable cynicism, it is instructive to consider the context in which the Minister took his decision.

An article by Lukas Muntingh points out the enormous impact of overcrowding, especially in communal cells and the risks this poses for the spread of the virus. The situation is made worse by the reduced amount of outside exercise inmates are allowed and the fact that no external visits are allowed. Most worrying is the lack of oversight that is usually provided by the Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services.

These realities are echoed by the current Inspecting Judge of Prisons, Edwin Cameron, in a News 24 article. He calls for oversight visits by the independent prison visitors of the Inspectorate to be reinstated. He points out that

Correctional centres are communities that exist on our peripheries. And yet, those inside are not peripheral.  They are not outsiders. And they do not live outside our society. They remain part of our community. Traffic in and out of our prisons continues daily.  We like to think we can lock people up and “throw away the key”. But we cannot.

Edwin cameron

Assisting paroled prisoners

It is in the light of these realties that organisations applauded the decision of the Minister to release 19,000 inmates on parole, for re-affirming government’s commitment to restorative justice and emphasizing that both victims and offenders need assistance.

The letter pointed out that the context into which these inmates will be released is an even harsher one than usual, and that these people may well be experienced by their families and communities as adding to the burden of survival. These unusually adverse socio-economic conditions together with the marginalisation and stigmatisation ex-offenders typically experience after release, increases their risk of re-offending. 

These inmates will be released is an even harsher one than usual, and that these people may well be experienced by their families and communities as adding to the burden of survival.

As restorative justice has been shown to reduce the risk of re-offending, the letter expressed concern at the current lack of support for restorative justice and called on the Minister to renew this, including by increasing access to funds from the National Lotteries Commission.

A premise of all the world’s major faiths is the concept of love, care and the desire to help. At this time of national disaster, faith communities often play a crucial role in providing food and other support to those around them. They would do well to draw on the resources of organisations who focus on supporting those released from prison. Some useful resources that can be leveraged include:

The release of 19,000 inmates does not need to become a sentence of a different kind for those who are paroled or their families, particularly as they have little chance of finding dignified work at this time. If we heed Cameron’s statement that prisoners — before and after release — are part of the community, then their well-being is our collective responsibility.

* The opinions expressed here by Spotlight.Africa contributors and editors are their own and not official statements of the Society of Jesus in South Africa or of the Catholic Church unless explicitly stated.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Mike Batley
Mike is from Pretoria, South Africa. In 2001 he co-founded and has since directed the Restorative Justice Centre (RJC), a vibrant and multi-cultural civil society organisation. Within this context he played a pioneering role in bringing restorative justice into the criminal justice system and public discourse, and in developing associated services. He was recognised as an Ashoka Fellow for this work. He has published several book chapters and journal articles on restorative justice which have also been quoted in 2 South African High Court judgments as well as 1 Constitutional Court judgment. He was part of the group of experts that reviewed the UN Basic Guidelines for Restorative Justice in November 2017. Mike is a registered social worker with over 30 years’ experience in the public and private sectors. He also holds an MPhil in Applied Ethics and is an accredited mediator. He is committed to the vision of building an ethical society and works as an independent practitioner in the areas of ethics, moral education, conflict transformation and wellness. For more information see

Most Popular

Thanksgiving is more than an American holiday

Thanksgiving is an annual holiday in the United States that brings together family and friends in a celebration of gratitude for the many blessings...

Pope appoints new bishops for Rustenburg and Witbank dioceses

At noon today it was announced by the Holy See's Press Office that the Holy Father Pope Francis has accepted the resignation of Bishop...

A grandmother’s love begins a journey of healing

Life Choices is a Salesian program that works with communities on the Cape Flats to help young people learn life skills that allows them...

In Gratitude: RIP Fr Emil Blaser OP

Tributes have been pouring in for Fr Emil Blaser, a pillar of Catholic media in South Africa, who passed away on 16 November. Russell...