Monday, October 26, 2020
27.1 C
Johannesburg
Home Opinion The Democratic Alliance sold us lies and paid the price

The Democratic Alliance sold us lies and paid the price

Twisting the truth for self-gain in the global political arena is sadly not uncommon. Mikhail Petersen highlights the uncomfortable truth that South Africa’s democracy has not been spared. Such tactics by the DA, the official South African majority opposition party, greatly compromises the democratic project.

In the lead up to the 2015 US election, I observed to my utter dismay, how fake news and outright lies had been utilised as a politicking strategy by Donald Trump’s presidential election campaign team. Fake news can be characterised as news, stories or hoaxes created to deliberately misinform or deceive readers

The realisation that the United States had found itself in a post-fact era was a bitter pill to swallow. This only culminated in the disbelief that was widely experienced when the official election results were released. And, the main proponent and architect of this phenomenon was inaugurated the 45th  US president. 

Such dirty tricks would, surely, never take root in our awesome constitutional democracy. The political parties in our nation were morally and ethically above this approach. Or so I thought.

I vividly remember in the days following the announced outcome, before Trump had been officially inaugurated, finding solace in the fact that the dirty tactics employed by the Trump campaign machine would never be used in South Africa. Such dirty tricks would, surely, never take root in our awesome constitutional democracy. The political parties in our nation were morally and ethically above this approach. Or so I thought.

Fast-forward to the 2019 national elections in South Africa and the very thing that kept me from losing all faith in the international political landscape happened on our doorstep. 

I realised this when the news broke that Democratic Alliance (DA) canvassers were instructed to tell voters that Patricia De Lille was fired from the party because of her corrupt activity in the City of Cape Town[1].

There was only one small problem with this message, disseminated by employed DA canvassers to hundreds and possibly thousands of prospective voters. De Lille was not fired by the DA. She resigned and all charges against her from within her former party were dropped.

The information that the DA was spreading was outright lies. Or to put it more diplomatically, the statements that were spread to these prospective voters in South Africa were ‘alternative facts.

The information that the DA was spreading was outright lies. Or to put it more diplomatically, the statements that were spread to these prospective voters in South Africa were ‘alternative facts.’ 

In an attempt to defend herself, De Lille then laid a charge against this version of the truth before the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) who ordered the DA to publicly apologise to De Lille within three days. 

Instead of admitting they were wrong, the DA once again took the Trumpian approach of ‘dying with the lie’, deciding to appeal the IEC finding. Their argument rides on the logic that it would not apologise unless ordered by a court., In the DA’s eyes the IEC fining has no force or effect. 

The telemarketing script given to DA employees canvassing for votes did not assist them in strengthening their position locally or nationally.

But there’s an irony to this all. The telemarketing script given to DA employees canvassing for votes did not assist them in strengthening their position locally or nationally. 

In terms of the results, nationally, the DA’s percentage of the vote fell from 22.23% in 2014 to 20.27% in 2019. Their provincial figures, in the Western Cape, dropped from 59.38% in 2014 to 55.45% in 2019. 

Spreading false information through inaccuracies, lies and fake news is against good democratic principles and practices. Such practices need to be treated and taken seriously by the public — and should result in a great uproar. 

If these actions go unchecked, treated merely as a passing media segment in the 24-hour media cycle — as happened in the US elections — then there is a strong possibility that these kinds​ of tactics by political parties will become commonplace. The erosion of core democratic values, which so many in this country have fought so hard to entrench would be inevitable.

* The opinions expressed here by Spotlight.Africa contributors and editors are their own and not official statements of the Society of Jesus in South Africa or of the Catholic Church unless explicitly stated.

3 COMMENTS

  1. It’s very true, as you say, that “spreading false information through inaccuracies, lies and fake news is against good democratic principles and practices.” But in the interests of accurate information the article ought to have disclosed that the Electoral Court ruled a week ago that the Commission’s finding against the DA was not competent, and set it aside. The Court also set aside the Commission’s decision that the DA’s statement that De Lille was fired was a false statement. So, as things stand, the DA’s position seems to have been vindicated. Maybe there’s such a thing as fake fake news?

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Mikhail Petersen
Mikhail Petersen holds a degree in Social Science, specialising in politics and economic history, as well as an LLB from the University of Cape Town. Mikhail is an intern within the Sustained Dialogue Programme at the Institute for Justice and Reconciliation, based in Cape Town.

Most Popular

Pope announces a consistory for the creation of 13 new cardinals

During the Angelus on Sunday, 25 October 2020, Pope Francis announced that he was going to create 13 new cardinals. Vatican News...

School culture at the heart of shaping new education futures

In a previous article, Mark Potterton described the educational potential of technology but cautioned against reducing learning to an online experience. In...

“Homosexual people have a right to be in a family… nobody should be thrown out,” says Pope Francis

Pope Francis is in the headlines again after a documentary film by the Russian Jew, Evgeny Afineevsky, was premiered at the Rome...

Getting back to normal — Is it even possible?

The world has changed dramatically in less than a year. Shrikant Peters looks beyond the immediate health crisis and examines the impact...

Archives